Online Dating Tips for Introverts: The Quiet Quest

Doublelist Team

January 5, 2024 8 minutes read
Connect with straight, gay, bi and curious!

Let’s face it: dating is daunting. Putting yourself out there, sending flirty messages, showing interest, and arranging an in-person date is a lot. Will they like me? Am I coming on too strong? Not strong enough? For introverts, these worries are a whole lot greater. If you’re less forward and find dating overwhelming, we’ve got you covered. Our online dating tips for introverts are here to help. 

See a profile you like, but you’re not sure what to do? Being an introvert on a dating site has its challenges. However, once you find that inner confidence and take that first step, it’s a whole new ball game. 

For all the introverts of the world, we’re here to help. Say goodbye to shy approaches and hello to a brave first step. Let’s get into it! 

Online Dating Sites: The Importance of the Right Platform 

In today’s modern world, there are many online dating sites to choose from. According to Forbes, there are 8,000 dating sites in the world. We know what you’re thinking: which is the right one for you? Well, this is where trial and error comes in. The only way to know what works for you is to try it out. But, as an introvert, this may be a challenging concept. 

With so many options, features, and styles, finding the right dating site requires some time. From swiping to filling your bio with witty information or creating personal ads, it all comes down to preference. 

To help you out, here are some dating apps that introverts may prefer:

  • Hinge. Hinge is a dating app for people looking for something more than a fling. It’s more focused on serious relationships, so you may find people less forward. You can fill in your bio and let people get to know you a bit without needing to say anything. 
  • DoubleList. You can browse the personal ads until you find one that stands out. It has lots of safety features, and you can easily report or block a profile. 
  • Bumble. On Bumble, the women or non-binary users can message first. So, you can leave it up to them to make the first move. 
  • Plenty of Fish. POF has so many members that you’re bound to find other introverts, easing the feeling of being overwhelmed. 
  • Anomo. This site lets you start with just an avatar, so you can remain incognito if you want. Over time, you can play games with other users, and the app matches you with like-minded people
  • Zoosk. The site uses an algorithm to get to know you and find you matches based on your actions. It also has ice-breakers to make the first move easier to take. 

If you’re a single person looking to mingle, there’s lots of choice. These are just some of the online dating sites you can use. They have features that make introverts feel more comfortable. Online dating sometimes takes a leap of faith, but these sites help to ease you in. 

Once you’ve found the right platform, it’s time for you to get active on it. But where to start? If you want to know our dating tips for the more reserved of the world, let’s get into it. 

Online Dating Tips for Introverts: The Key to Connections

Online dating is daunting for many people, and more people than you think find it overwhelming. If you’re an introvert, the thought of virtually approaching people, flirting, and dating may seem like a lot. However, we’ve compiled a list of our top tips for reserved daters so you can enjoy the online dating experience. After all, it’s supposed to be fun! 

Here are our online dating tips for introverts:

1. Find the Right Site or App

As discussed above, the right platform is essential for introverts when online dating. Some sites may feel too forward, making you feel overwhelmed. Try out a few different online dating apps and find one that feels right. You may enjoy the features of one more than another and feel more comfortable making your move. It all comes down to personal preference and what makes you feel at ease. 

2. Ease Yourself In

It’s okay to feel intimidated and overwhelmed. People use dating apps for a wide range of reasons, and they may be feeling the same. Instead of forcing yourself to dive into the world of dating, do a little bit a day. Take your time, and don’t put too much pressure on yourself. It’s okay to feel nervous, but easing yourself in may help. 

3. Take Your Time Building Your Profile 

Your profile acts as a first impression, so it’s essential to take your time building it. If you feel comfortable, add in your hobbies and interests, as they’re often good ice-breakers. Create a good headline, too. This will help your profile catch people’s eye.

If you’re looking for something specific, like a potential partner or a local hookup, say that. There’s nothing wrong with being direct about what you want. Choose high-quality, happy-looking photos for your profile. You’re more likely to attract people’s attention. 

4. Don’t Hold Back From Making the First Move 

Making the first move shows confidence, which is attractive. Even if you feel nervous, taking that step shows your interest. Who doesn’t like to feel complimented by someone showing interest? Taking that leap is daunting, but it’s the only way to get you where you want to be. If you see a profile that catches your eye, take the risk and send that message! 

5. Prepare Ice-Breakers or Questions

Thinking of what to say on the spot is sometimes tricky. There’s nothing wrong with a little pre-planning ahead of time. The dating scene is full of people asking questions because that’s the best way to get to know someone. Open-ended questions are usually the best option, as it’s easier to keep the conversation going. Having a few under your belt may ease your nerves and make you feel more prepared. 

6. Look for Common Interests 

Finding common interests is a good way to know if you’re a match or not. By looking at people’s profiles, you may find some interests or hobbies that you also enjoy. These could be great ice-breakers. Also, people love talking about themselves and what they enjoy. So, spark up a conversation about their interests in their profile. They’ll appreciate the chance to discuss it. They’ve included it in their profile for a reason, so use it to your advantage. 

7. Be Light-Hearted 

Online dating is, or should be, enjoyable. When under the influence of nerves, the fun can quickly slip away. Try to remember that you’re on the site to get to know new people and see where it leads you. It’s supposed to be fun! Try to avoid being too direct, to the point, or serious. 

8. Plan Activities for In-Person Dates 

Planning offline dates is all part of the experience. Even though it’ll be out of your comfort zone, only plan to meet in person when you feel ready. If you find a connection with someone you’ve been speaking to online, meeting in person is the next step. Try planning fun activities to help break the ice initially. Choose lively, fun locations and do something fun. 

For your first date, feeling comfortable is essential. Dress in clothes that you feel comfortable in. This will help you feel more confident. Dress to impress, of course, but don’t go overboard or wear something that’s not you. It’s hard to be yourself or good company if you feel uncomfortable. 

9. Be Yourself 

Being yourself is crucial to successful online dating. If you want to build connections or meet a potential partner, showing the real you is important. This is crucial if you plan to meet them in person eventually. There’s nothing wrong with being introverted. In fact, according to LinkedIn, between 30-50% of the population is introverted. Introverts, by nature, are more reserved than extroverts, and being yourself is key. 

Online dating as an introvert is often overwhelming and daunting. However, by following these tips, you can navigate the online dating world and find connections. Even if you’re introverted, there are plenty of potential matches waiting for you. All it takes is confidence to make the first move, open-ended questions, and the right dating site for your preferences. Be yourself and let the matches roll in. 

Ready To Put Your Online Dating Tips to the Test? Try DoubleList! 

DoubleList is a highly open-minded community where people can explore their preferences. It’s a great place for introverts to discover the realm of possibility and interact with people just like them. The site’s active in 248 locations, so there’ll be plenty of introverts waiting to make connections, just like you! 
Now you’ve heard our online dating tips for introverts, put them to use on DoubleList. Sign up today!

Unlock your wildest fantasies and connect with locals today!

Connect with straight, gay, bi and curious!