Book of Matches Review: The Real Free Dating Site!

Doublelist Team

August 14, 2023 8 minutes read
Connect with straight, gay, bi and curious!

Many dating sites promise a free account. Most don’t deliver when it comes to features and results. Some free accounts require payment to connect with your matches. What about Book of Matches? It boasts an entirely free account with no hidden fees. Find out more in this Book of Matches review and see if this site lives up to its promises! 

Book of Matches Review: Is It Completely Free?

Yes, Book of Matches is a 100% free dating platform. This means you can access all its features without upgrades. It offers a fully functioning matchmaking system, communication channels and social networking elements. It also takes extra care of your security with a quality membership score. 

Book of Matches is one of the oldest dating platforms, with 2 million active users worldwide. It welcomes straight, gay and lesbian users. You can choose from friends, casual dating and long-term relationships.    

In this Book of Matches review, we’ll discuss the site in more detail to determine if it’s worth trying. From its registration process and user base profile to user experience and features, we cover it all.

1. Double list - Dating in a bar

Book of Matches Free Review: Setting up Your Account

Book of Matches has a simple registration process. To sign up, you need an email address, a username and a password. After the site approves your username, you will fill in your details to create a profile. 

The site is public, so your data will be available to everyone who opens it. If you wish to keep some information private, you can leave some sections empty. But according to users’ Book of Matches reviews, you should fill in as much data as possible to get matches. So it’s up to you to decide which information is worth sharing.

Here are essential factors you should include according to users’ Book of Matches free reviews:

  • Physical traits that include height, weight, eye color and hair color

  • Current relationship status

  • Your current city

  • A catchy headline on your profile

Book of Matches Review: Who Will You Meet on the Site?

Although Book of Matches has fewer users, they’re active and legit. Thanks to their user review feature, you’re less likely to see fake profiles on this site. You can also detect fake profiles by checking out their user quality rating.

The site has users ranging from 18 to 55 years of age. They also seem to have a balanced gender ratio with slightly more male members. A downside is that finding matches outside of major cities can be challenging.

Book of Matches Review: What Features Are Available?

Book of Matches offers basic features, matchmaking features and communication channels. Book of Matches users can view profiles and create favorite lists. The site has a profile quality score that shows whether a user is legit. You can also send friend requests to use it as a networking site. 

You can use personality tests and suggestions using the site’s matchmaking features. Use the search feature based on location, preference or orientation to find your perfect match. The personality tests are helpful to give you suggestions for suitable matches on the platform. 

Book of Matches has plenty of communication channels. You can send instant messages to online members or emails to offline members. There are also audio and video chat options to get more intimate.

3. Doublelist - biking

Book of Matches Dating Site Review: User Experience

Some Book of Matches dating site reviews praised the platform for finding great matches, which later turned into relationships. However, there are several complaints about the website’s login process. The site resolved this in 2019 and had no issues when we checked.  

Book of Matches Review: Pros & Cons 

To summarize our Book of Matches review, the dating site has some pros and cons.


  • It’s completely free

  • Various communication channels

  • User quality rating

  • Great matchmaking features


  • No mobile application

  • Small user base 

Book of Matches Review: Free Dating Site Alternatives 

Whilst the site has lots of great features to offer, there are also significant downsides to consider. Plenty of other dating sites offer free accounts with better features. Our list of alternatives below is worth considering if you think Book of Matches isn’t quite what you’re after. 

Whether it’s for hookups or serious relationships, we have it all. So read on and choose the one that fits your needs.

Let the Algorithm Find Your Match: Download OkCupid

OkCupid is a free dating site that uses algorithms to give you match recommendations. The platform offers a more inclusive dating scene, including gender-fluid and non-binary options. OkCupid has more users than Book of Matches, with 50 million members.

OkCupid will ask you questions to find suitable matches during the sign-up process. You’ll see your compatibility with other users when you swipe through the interface. 

Although it has a paid version, you can use most of its features without spending a dime. You’ll be able to make matches and send messages for free. With paid versions, you can receive unlimited likes and super likes and see people who like you. These features can save time and improve your match rates. Opt for this version if you want to be more efficient. 

Comparing OkCupid with our Book of Matches review, the platform has a larger user base and helpful algorithms. But the Book of Matches has more communication channels. Using OkCupid can save you time and is more likely to match you with someone desirable. 

5. Doublelist - Dating App

Book of Matches Review Alternative: Adventurous Zoosk

Zoosk is another massive platform with 35 million members. This site is great for hookups, casual dating and serious relationships. Zoosk also uses algorithms to find your best matches according to the information you fill in during sign-up. On Zoosk, you can choose between free and paid versions. 

The free version has virtual dates, live, smart pick and carousel pick. Smart Pick gives you a list of profiles that matches you. In contrast, carousel pick lets you use the swipe method to find matches.

The paid version of Zoosk gives you extra perks. With paid coins, you can send gifts, boost your profiles and send a broadcast message to many users. These features are great additions to the basic features. But the free version is still an excellent option to find matches. 

Zoosk is a better platform if we compare it with our Book of Matches review. It offers more users and excellent algorithm matchmaking features. 

6. Doublelist - brush

Book of Matches Review Alternative: Plenty of Fish

Plenty of Fish is one of the biggest online dating platforms, with over 150 million users worldwide. The site is more popular among serious daters. It offers free and premium memberships. 

Once you sign up, you’ll see a ‘Meet Me’ section. This page shows you photos of singles that match your desires. You can choose the ones you like, and if you match, you can start messaging. 

They also have an online game and compatibility quiz to help matches get to know each other. All these features are available in the free memberships, but you’re limited with the number of likes, messages and views.

Their premium version allows you to upload more pictures, send unlimited messages and give unlimited likes. It also provides access to live streaming whilst boosting your profile and allowing you to see who viewed it. 

Plenty of Fish offers a fun approach to dating with its playful features. Use this site if you’re looking for committed relationships.

10. Doublelist - Dance

A Free Dating Site for Serious Relationships:

Founded in 1995, is a pioneer in online dating. With over 21 million users, this platform offers plenty of choices.’s members are primarily between 30 to 49 years of age. Most users are looking for serious and committed relationships. 

The site matches you with other users based on information on your profile. It will give you new matches every day. You can send messages if you find someone who interests you.

The platform offers free and premium membership subscriptions. Free members can browse profiles, send likes and message top picks. These are decent enough if you’re not in a hurry to find dates. The paid version gives you a profile boost, rewinds, super like and unlimited messaging. You also can see who opened your profile. is a worthy competitor when we compare it with our Book of Matches review. You’re able to see more profiles thanks to its massive user base. But it lacks the fun features available when using Book of Matches.

Best Personal Ads Dating Site: Versatility With DoubleList

DoubleList is a dating platform that works like the Craigslist Personals section. It’s one of the most inclusive platforms. It doesn’t matter what your orientation and sexual preferences are; you’re welcome to sign up. The platform has 10 million members worldwide.

Signing up on DoubleList is free, and the process takes less than 10 minutes. You can post and respond to personal ads, which is great for finding matches if you’re new to online dating. There are also forums and blogs where you can find like-minded people. 

Our platform also offers a premium membership where you can post multiple ads, send unlimited messages and use video chat. You can also use the advanced filter that gives you the best matches on DoubleList.

If we compare DoubleList to our Book of Matches review, it offers more members, diverse users and more features. So what are you waiting for? Sign up to DoubleList today and find your perfect match!

Unlock your wildest fantasies and connect with locals today!

Connect with straight, gay, bi and curious!

Leave a Comment